Lost of past

Is easy conciliate the manly person of John Huss and Allan
Kardec, however is very hard see this self spirit
such Francisco Cândido Xavier

“If God considered it convenient that a veil be cast over the past it is because
it is to our advantage that this be so.” – The Gospel According
to Spiritism, cap. V, item 11
 

Sometimes, recommendations of Jesus, Kardec and others spiritual benefactors are left in favor of passionate personal positions. We have recent examples in the question about the identity of Francisco Cândido Xavier and André Luiz.  

In the case of the famous medium, this recommendation shall be applied completely. If exists true interest by Spiritual Word in the revelation of past life, the Superior Spirits would just be in the nick of time. But, what is the purpose of such a revelation?  In which will be increase the credibility either medium’s or spiritist message? 

Have many people, incarnated and disincarnated, who like one controversy. As soon as disappear one, they create one new. A few people will saying what is don’t incarnated’s opinion, since what one message was received from a know medium and, recently, in one psychographed book, was made the affirmation about the Kardec’s return in personality of Chico Xavier. In this particular question, we remember words of Emmanuel about others “revelations” made by disincarnated spirits, in the question what Jesus lived between the Essenes, what the benefactor deny: “Even the spheres closer to the Earth, which under the circumstances they approach most of the controversies of men of learning of the sincere spirit of selfless orb, reflect the conflicting views of humanity, about the Savior of all creatures”. (Toward the Light, chapter 12.)

About André Luiz was been Carlos Chagas (picture), how want someone, this subject have more deep character And what to say about the “Greeting of Allan Kardec”, psychographed by Julio César Grandi Ribeiro, in the night of 02 de January of 1984, in commemoration of centenary by Federação Espírita Brasileira and the transfer of your head-quarter to Brasilia, according published in the magazine “Reformador” in March

1984? Well, who want continue arguing, we know that can say that  Chico could have your physical body in Uberaba, possibly writing psychography messages that time – was Friday – and have gone to Brasilia, doing one great psychological revolution in itself, to present themselves as Kardec…

Is easy conciliate the virile personality of John Huss and Kardec, but is difficult see the same Spirit present themselves as Francisco Cândido Xavier. Is, this way, very easy to one Spirit made the truth psychological revolution? Take as an example the performance of Elijah, which is repeated in John the Baptist, some centuries later. 

As for André Luiz was Carlos Chagas, as they want some, now reinforced in their convictions by mediunic work, the subject takes more serious character, before the famous scientist's fact still to have red descendants. The appeal was not enough to the good-sense, it would be easy to verify data: It is not difficult to calculate the time of André Luiz's death, being taken by their base conversations with Lísias: “You aren't aware yet, are you, that your stay in the lower spheres lasted over eight years”. (Astral City, pp. 38). 

In August of 1939, André Luiz heard Lísias, which talked about the imminence of Second World War (Astral City, pp. 107).

It can be deduced that André Luiz was already disincarnated in 1930, while Carlos Chagas died in 1934 

Then it can be deduced that was already disincarnated there is, at least, nine years, once it was already perfectly healthy. For that calculation, he should have disincarnated, at the most, in 1930. Carlos Chagas died on November 8, 1934, 55 years old. 

It should be noticed that André Luiz must have received little doctor's title besides the 25 years. Therefore, she practiced medicine for 15 years, dead with little more than 40. André Luiz declares that he left in the Earth a son and two daughters. Carlos Chagas, two children. 

Besides, André Luiz is characterized perfectly as doctor, clinic doctor, for the words of Clarêncio: ”(…)I also found that, in your fifteen years of medical practice, six thousand poor patients received free medical attendance in your clinic.” (Astral City pp. 68).

“With your lips you ask for any kind of work, but deep in your heart what you really miss is your consulting room, your patients, and all the atmosphere of medical service with which the Lord deigned to honor you on Earth.” (Astral City pp. 65). 

In that reference to his work in the Earth, anything that could identify with the eminent scientist: researcher, bacteriologist and hygienist, that Carlos Chagas, that was devoted to the bacteriology since their times of student was. Scientist globally recognized, he was teacher of University of Medicine of Rio de Janeiro; he received the title Magister Honoris Causes of the Universities of Harvard and of Paris; he belonged to the scientific academies of New York, Paris and Lima; it was rewarded with medal of gold by the University of Hamburg (Kummel’s Prize); two years it passed traveling for the it is worth Amazonian, lifting the epidemic letter of the area; ahead of prophylactic campaign, it eradicated the malaria in the city of Santos; it was Managing of the Instituto Oswaldo Cruz from 1917 to 1934, when he died.

What did in the terrestrial scenery change so that André Luiz's identity was revealed? Who does this benefit? 

It is of seeing that the innovation encourages so much, to the point of those that if they put the divulge it if they forget of the words of Emmanuel when presenting André Luiz, in the foreword of "Astral City": “There are no social records for a physician named André Luiz. Often real understanding and true love come us hidden under the cloak of anonymity (...). Thus, we cannot introduce an earthly doctor and human writer, but instead present a new friend and brother in eternity”. 

And everything indicates that the anonymity didn't elapse of personal decision of Emmanuel, before what is read in the work "Voltei", in the end of the cap. 2: “His work is impersonal and reflecting the cooperation, in indirect way, of many our benefactors who they breathe out in more advanced spheres”. 

Before that, it would be of asking: Who did the anonymity determine was suspended? What did in the terrestrial scenery change so that André Luiz's identity was revealed? Which the benefit of that assumed revelation, to not the one to be of provoking sterile discussions? In what those "revelations" do contribute to the people's enlightenment? 

Would not it be better occupy our time in mediunics meetings destined to explain to siblings that suffer?  

Doesn't the Spiritism have as flag the charity? Charity to disincarnates sufferers, to children that lack spiritualistic orientation through the evangelization.